The Royal Academy Conversazione, 1891
3 of 11 portraits of John Callcott Horsley
The Royal Academy Conversazione, 1891
by G. Grenville Manton
Pen and ink and gouache, with traces of pencil, on wove paper laid down on a strawboard secondary support, 1891
17 3/4 in. x 24 1/8 in. (450 mm x 614 mm)
Click on the links below to find out more:
Inscriptionback to top
Signed and dated lower left: G. Grenville Manton / 1891.
This portraitback to top
Oct. 2014: edited by AE - so this version no longer valid.
G. Grenville Manton (1855-1932) was a portrait painter and illustrator; he was a staff artist on the illustrated magazine Black & White from the 1890s.  This is a large watercolour drawing for a double-spread engraving in the publication, dated 27 June 1891 and entitled The Royal Academy Conversazione - The President and Council Receiving the Guests. 
From the foundation of the Royal Academy in 1768, it had been the custom to hold an annual dinner to mark the birthday of the Sovereign. In 1851 this was abolished in favour of the yearly soirée, which allowed the participation of a greater number of guests, at a more economical rate per head.  The loss of the former tradition was not an entirely popular alteration. In his parody of the institution written in 1890, Harry Furniss records his perspective of the event:
Watch the crowd, as I have, going down, anticipating refreshments worthy of their host, the Royal Academy of England! And watch them coming up! the victims of bitter disappointment exasperated with the niggardly provision made for the guests and hungry and affronted. The only way to make an Englishman pleased is to satisfy his stomach I firmly believe this refreshment antic of the Royal Academy does more to injure the reputation of that mean society than any starving of Art in the eyes of the great British public. 
In contrast, the text accompanying the published engraving in Black & White describes a more elegant and orderly spectacle, which in 1891 took place on Wednesday 24 June:
A continuous stream of carriages block the way of Piccadilly for hours, depositing the occupants at the door of Burlington House. Up the broad flower-lined stairway flocks the cream of Londons fashion and beauty and the Art, Literature and Science, the Services and the Law, Connoisseurship and the Aristocracy, all are worthily represented in this great annual Academy festival the crowded rooms afford plenty of amusement in the meeting of ones friends, in listening to the fine military band in the sculpture room, and, for many, in looking out for whos who, or in the refreshment room downstairs. And so the brilliant throng passed the pleasant hours, and not until midnight has sounded does the rumble of the last carriage awaken the echoes of Piccadilly, and the tired porter swings to the massive gates that close in the sacred precincts of Burlington House. 
Manton effectively captures the grandeur and formality of this event and provides a fitting illustration to the accompanying text:
At the vestibule the guests are announced by the gorgeously-attired porters to the President, who, surrounded by his Council, receives them with the graciousness and amiable courtesy for which he is renowned: with a smile and a handshake for his friends, or a dignified bow for those outside his immediate circle of acquaintanceship. It is a favourite custom of guests who have already passed the President to stand behind the banks of flowers and watch the charming way in which Sir Frederic Leighton discharges his tedious function. 
Indeed, there is a narrative element to the artists composition: on the right-hand side, guests wait to be announced beside one of the two porters, who will call their name from a card, presumably provided by them upon arrival at the head of the queue. In the centre of the composition Frederic Leighton president of the institution since 1878 is solemnly engaged in this ritual, the couple before him poised at the moment of greeting after advancing towards him from their place in the line. Amongst the watching figures grouped behind the foliage are portraits of the leading artistic figures of the day, the majority of whom were Royal Academicians.
The image includes thirty-eight heads. Twenty-three were identified in the published caption in 1891; in 1936 Marion Harry Spielmann listed twenty-eight names.  In 2004 the NPG Complete Illustrated Catalogue confirmed twenty-six identifications, and this figure has now been expanded to twenty-seven, with the inclusion of John Calcott Horsley. This artist was a prominent member of the Academy and likely to be present at such an event; he can be partly seen behind the left shoulder of the Hall Porter to the right-hand side of the room, and in front of Mary Anderson. 
Four full-length figures in the foreground remain unidentified, which is surprising, considering the prominence of their position and their size within the composition. The two individuals engaged in greeting Leighton have their backs to the viewer so that their features are obscured. They are perhaps more representative of a type, the typical attendees of the soirée. In contrast, the features of the two young women standing at the front of the queue one with a mass of dark hair and the other holding a fan are so detailed and distinct that they were undoubtedly intended as specific likenesses. Between the heads of the two women is Henry Tanworth Wells. It is possible that these figures are his two daughters, and that he is standing beside them in line, waiting to introduce them to the president. Alice Joanna Street and Joanna Margaret Hadley would have been in their early thirties in 1891.  Moreover, the woman holding the fan bears a strong resemblance to Alice, who was represented next to her father by Henry Jamyn Brooks in his group portrait, Private View at the Old Masters Exhibition, 1888 (NPG 1833). The same delicate nose, distinctive eyebrows and rounded chin, are evident in each depiction.
NPG 2820 is the only work by Manton in the collection at the National Portrait Gallery. It was purchased from M.H. Spielmann in 1936, when he initially attempted to sell his entire collection of about eighty portrait drawings of artists to the Gallery. In 1935, Henry Hake director from 1927 to 1951 visited his home in Folkstone, Kent to view and discuss the works.  Ultimately, the Gallery acquired eleven drawings for the sum of £100.  Spielmann was an important art and literary critic. He wrote for numerous publications including the Pall Mall Gazette, and was editor of the Magazine of Art from 1886 to 1904. He was also a friend of many leading artists of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In a letter to Hake detailing the sitters identified by him in Mantons watercolour, Spielmann explains: As to the list all of them except four were friends of mine and now all are gone! except the modest survivor.  Before the drawing was engraved on wood for publication Spielmann, whose portrait was included by the artist without his prior knowledge, requested that the likeness be changed to represent the actor and theatre manager Sir John Hare. 
Like Brooks before him, Manton ambitiously tackled the problem of including multiple group portraits within a single composition, whilst presenting the illusion that the scene was observed in its entirety rather than constructed in a piecemeal fashion. Unfortunately, there is little documentary evidence to describe the artists working process. Considering the small scale of the image and its essentially descriptive purpose in a prominent publication, it is likely that Manton relied on photographic likenesses to represent each sitter as an alternative to live sittings. The head of John Pettie for example, between Briton Riviere and Lawrence Alma-Tadema, bears resemblance to a photograph of the artist published in 1888 in The Years Art,  a publication that would have been easily accessible to Manton. It was published annually and included numerous photographic portraits of RAs and ARAs. Even the angle of the head, inclined slightly to the left, is the same. In another example, the profile pose of John Seymour Lucas, to the extreme left, is almost identical to the familiar Van der Weyde photograph of the 1880s. This image was also published in The Years Art in 1899, and as wood-engravings in the Graphic and the Art Journal, in 1886 and 1887 respectively. 
Left to right:
John Seymour Lucas (1849-1923)
Dame (Alice) Ellen Terry (1847-1928)
Sir William Quiller Orchardson (1832-1910)
Rachel, Countess of Dudley (1867-1920)
Marcus Stone (1840-1921)
Henry Stacy Marks (1829-1898)
Sir Henry Irving (1838-1905)
Unidentified man (Hall Porter)
Sir John Everett Millais, 1st Bt (1829-1896)
William Charles Thomas Dobson (1817-1898)
James Sant (1820-1916)
William Powell Frith (1819-1909)
Sir Hubert von Herkomer (1849-1914)
Briton Riviere (1840-1920)
John Pettie (1839-1893)
Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema (1836-1912)
Frederic Leighton, Baron Leighton (1830-1896)
Philip Hermogenes Calderon (1833-1898)
Walter William Ouless (1848-1933)
Thomas Faed (1826-1900)
Robert Walker Macbeth (1848-1910)
(Edward) Onslow Ford (1852-1901)
William Frederick Yeames (1835-1918)
Sir Edward Coley Burne-Jones, 1st Bt (1833-1898)
Unidentified man (Hall Porter)
Mary Anderson (Mrs de Navarro) (1859-1940)
John Calcott Horsley (1817-1904)
Joanna Margaret Hadley? (daughter of H.T. Wells)
Henry Tanworth Wells (1828-1903)
Alice Joanna Street? (daughter of H.T. Wells)
Marion Harry Spielmann (1858-1948)
Footnotesback to top
1) Houfe 1996, p.262.
2) Engraved in the Black and White Studio [unidentified wood-engraver], Black & White, 27 June 1891, p.677.
3) Text accompanying the engraving, Black & White, 27 June 1891, p.677. In 1891 the contract for the catering was given to Mr Whaley of Limmers Hotel. A rate of 3s a head was charged for the first 1000 guests, 2s a head for the second 1000 and 1s a head for any over 2000; Royal Academy Annual Report 1891, p.11.
4) Furniss 1890b, p.80.
5) Black & White, 27 June 1891, p.677; see also Royal Academy Annual Report 1891, p.11.
6) Black & White, 27 June 1891, p.677.
7) Handwritten list accompanying typed letter from M.H. Spielmann to H.M. Hake, 6 Apr. 1936, NPG RP 281020. In this list, Spielmann also notes the Hall Porter for many years, to the right of the composition.
8) NPG CIC 2004, p.717. In his list of sitters, Spielmann incorrectly identified Robert Browning (18121889) in the place of Horsley. Even if this was intended as a posthumous representation, Mantons likeness is of a much younger man than Browning, who was well into his seventies at the time of his death.
9) Although the birth and death dates for each sister are unknown, it has been established that their mother, Joanna Mary Boyce, married H.T Wells in 1857 and died in 1861. Therefore, it can be assumed that her daughters were born within this four-year interval.
10) Internal memorandum from H.M. Hake, 20 Aug. 1935, NPG RP 281020.
11) Internal memorandum from H.M. Hake, 3 Feb. 1936; letter from H.M. Hake to M.H. Spielmann, 18 Mar. 1936; letter from M.H. Spielmann to H.M. Hake, 24 Mar., 1936, all NPG RP 281020. See also NPG Report of the Trustees 19367, p.4, NPG Archive.
12) Letter from M.H. Spielmann to H.M. Hake, 6 Apr. 1936, NPG RP 281020.
13) Spielmann added a note to his list of sitters, included with a letter to H.M. Hake, 6 Apr. 1936: This portrait was introduced by the artist without M.H.S.'s knowledge, by whose direction it was changed by Manton into one of Sir John Hare for the engraving on wood for a large double-page in Black & White; NPG RP 281020.
14) The Years Art 1888, p.56; photograph by George Whitfield.
15) The Years Art 1889, p.116; Graphic, 13 Mar. 1886, p.280; AJ, 1886, p.65.
Referenceback to top
Furniss, H., Royal Academy Antics, London, 1890.
Houfe, S., The Dictionary of 19th-Century British Book Illustrators and Caricaturists, Woodbridge, Suffolk, 1996 (rev. ed. of Houfe 1978).
Jones et al. 1996
Jones, S., and others, Frederic Leighton 18301896, exh. cat., Royal Academy, London, 1996.
NPG CIC 2004
Saywell, D., and J. Simon, National Portrait Gallery: Complete Illustrated Catalogue, NPG, London, 2004 (first edition 1981).
Ormond & Ormond 1975
Ormond, L., and R. Ormond, Lord Leighton, London, 1975.
Swanson, V.G., Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema: Painter of the Victorian Vision of the Ancient World, London, 1977.
Physical descriptionback to top
Half length,slightly to left, facing, hair greying and parted at centre
Exhibitionsback to top
Victorian Era Exhibition (Historical Section), London, 1897 (190, p.36 in cat.).
Reproductionsback to top
Black & White, 27 June 1891, p.677.
Ormond & Ormond 1975, pl.145.
Swanson 1977, p.28.
L. Ormond, Leighton and the Royal Academy in Jones et al. 1996, p.16, fig.3.
View all known portraits for Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema
View all known portraits for Sir Edward Coley Burne-Jones, 1st Bt
View all known portraits for Philip Hermogenes Calderon
View all known portraits for Thomas Faed
View all known portraits for (Edward) Onslow Ford
View all known portraits for William Powell Frith
View all known portraits for Sir Hubert von Herkomer
View all known portraits for John Callcott Horsley
View all known portraits for Frederic Leighton, Baron Leighton
View all known portraits for John Seymour Lucas
View all known portraits for Henry Stacy Marks
View all known portraits for Sir John Everett Millais, 1st Bt
View all known portraits for Sir William Quiller Orchardson
View all known portraits for John Pettie
View all known portraits for James Sant
View all known portraits for Marion Harry Spielmann
View all known portraits for Marcus Clayton Stone
View all known portraits for Dame Ellen Alice Terry
View all known portraits for Henry Tanworth Wells
View all known portraits for William Frederick Yeames
Exhibitions and displays
- Curators' Choice: Photographs from the Terence Pepper Gift
Until 24 January 2016
- ‘The artist’s cause at heart’: M.H. Spielmann, Collector and Donor
Until 19 September
- Sir Edward Burne-Jones
- Princes of Victorian Bohemia
- Fernando Meacci
- Only Connect - installation video
- Only Connect
- Sir Henry Irving
- A Celebration of Shakespeare
- Later Victorian Portraits Catalogue
- Frederic Leighton
- Only Connect - Frederic Leighton <> Joseph Joachim
- G.F Watts - Selected Letters
- Photographic holdings - prints Collections
- Handlist of names in the Reference Collection