Sir Henry Irving
- Extended catalogue entry
Sir Henry Irving
by Harry M. Allen, after Sir John Everett Millais, 1st Bt
Oil on canvas, late 19th century, based on a work of 1884
43 7/8 in. x 32 in. (1115 mm x 814 mm) overall
Inscriptionback to top
Labels on stretcher bars:
(a) printed with text in red: ‘DRAWING MATERIALS. / FROM / CHARLES ROBERSON & CO. / 99, Long Acre, London.’;
and inscr.: ‘H.M. Allen Esq / The Garrick Club / Garrick Street WC’.
(b) another Roberson label of the same format, very worn.
This portraitback to top
NPG 1453 is a faithful replica of a painting of Irving by John Everett Millais, which has always hung in the Garrick Club, London. The copyist was Harry Milward Allen, now little known but active in the first quarter of the twentieth century. The story of how this replica came to be accepted by the National Portrait Gallery Trustees, and its fate after 1910, sheds a curious light on Gallery acquisition policy of the time.
Irving liked his portrait by Millais.  It is clear from the correspondence that the artist made the first advances, in July 1883, and that sittings were few and rushed.  Not everybody shared Irving’s satisfaction with the outcome, however, and some questioned its value as a likeness; for instance, his biographer Percy Fitzgerald thought it ‘rather sketchily painted, and lack[ing] force and expression’; and Harry Furniss, who had spent decades studying the actor’s face and movements, made the same point: ‘Millais’ portrait […] gives one no idea of strength, and Irving had a strong face. And as he frequently sat under this portrait it was easy to contrast the original with the picture.’  Ellen Terry thought Irving’s views on his portraiture quite misguided: ‘Henry had a strange affection for the wrong pictures of himself. He disliked the Bastien Lepage, the Whistler, and the Sargent, which never even saw the light. He adored the weak, handsome picture by Millais….’ 
After Irving died in October 1905 memorials were organized. Seeing there was no major portrait in a public collection, and as owners of an oils Irving had ‘adored’ (and which had become famous through reproduction),  a group of Garrick Club members decided to present a replica of their Millais portrait to the NPG. The experienced copyist Allen was given the ‘difficult task’; and as the original was ‘fixed in its frame in the Strangers’ Dining Room’ he may have worked at the Club. 
As a copyist and occasional portrait painter, Harry Allen is very well documented at the NPG. His name first appears in the Gallery’s Register of applications to copy, NPG 77/5, when he spent two years from 1902 copying the famous portrait of Charles Dickens by Daniel Maclise (NPG 1172).  He registered at the Gallery again at various dates between 1909 and 1912; and for a last time in 1926.  In the registers he signed variously ‘H. Allen’; ‘Harry Allen’; ‘H.M. Allen’; ‘Harry M. Allen’; and ‘Harry Milward Allen’, with addresses in Putney.
Correspondence between the Garrick Club and the Gallery regarding the copy began in January 1907, once the painting was finished, when the club secretary Charles Fitch offered to put copy and original ‘near each other’ for inspection.  Allen’s painting was accepted by the NPG Trustees in February. The World reported it had been an unusual transaction, with some bending of the rules by both institutions:
[The Garrick] committee, as guardians of the interests of its members, very properly refuse to allow any of its wonderful collection of art treasures to be reproduced. They made an exception in the case of this portrait of Sir Henry Irving, on the distinct proviso that the copy should be offered to the trustees of the National Portrait Gallery as a present to the nation by the Garrick Club. The [NPG] trustees, on their part, handsomely waived two of their standing orders, one that no portrait shall be accepted until the person it portrays shall have been dead ten years, and another that only originals, and not copies, shall be hung in the Gallery. 
Henry Irving was represented at the Gallery by NPG 1453 until February 1910, when Ellen Terry offered to present a portrait of the actor painted from life by Jules Bastien-Lepage (NPG 1560). For the director Charles Holmes, who considered the Allen painting had no ‘great intrinsic merit’ and was ‘valuable rather as filling a gap in the collection’,  this offer was exciting. But it had potential for causing offence, too: Bastien-Lepage’s portrait showed up the deficiencies of the Allen; they could not hang side by side, yet both were important gifts to the nation. Holmes needed to make discreet preliminary enquiries, as revealed in a letter from a friend (almost certainly Horace Hannyngton Child, assistant editor of the Burlington Magazine) in January 1910:
I learned on Friday at the Garrick that the proposal to present the N.P.G. with the Millais copy was but coldly received [by the Garrick committee in 1907?], & that practically the whole expense & trouble were borne by the man whose idea it was. And he is dead. The opinion I received was that the best thing to do was the simplest also – just offer it on loan where you please & say nothing about it – at any rate beyond a formal notification of the deed. They would be glad of the picture at Stratford in the Shakespeare memorial. All this of course in confidence.
How goes it with thee, o man of men? […]
Thine H.C. 
Accordingly Holmes lost no time in negotiating with the Shakespeare Memorial at Stratford. On 15 February 1910 Charles Fitch wrote that the Garrick committee ‘have no objection to your loaning the portrait of Sir Henry Irving to the Shakespeare memorial at Stratford-on-Avon as suggested’.  The picture was dispatched to Stratford in March 1910, and there it remained – fortunately unharmed by a fire in 1926 – until the 1960s, the one representation of Irving at Stratford.  Finally, prompted it seems by the threat of annual insurance fees, the Royal Shakespeare Company asked to terminate the loan agreement, and the painting was returned to the Gallery on 21 June 1967. 
Footnotesback to top
1) Millais, who was about ten years older than Irving, joined the Garrick Club in 1855; Irving in 1874. He was a pall-bearer at Millais’s funeral in 1896.
2) Letter from J.E. Millais to H. Irving, 15 Nov. 1882, Henry Irving Correspondence, Ref. No.2521 (THM/37/7/32); and letter from J.E. Millais to H. Irving, 23 July 1883, Henry Irving Correspondence, Ref. No.2522 (THM/37/7/32).
3) Fitzgerald 1906, p.153. See also Spielmann 1898, p.151.
4) Furniss 1906, p.42.
5) Terry 1908, p.123.
6) For the print by Thomas Oldham Barlow (NPG D8100 and other copies, see ‘All known portraits, I. In private character, Paintings, drawings, sculptures and prints, publ. 1885’.
7) See Spielmann 1898, p.151. See also the Roberson label on the stretcher, which is addressed to H.M. Allen at the Garrick Club.
8) This copy now Portsmouth M. and Records Service, acc.2005/1591 (undated).
9) See NPG Archive, ‘Student Signatures Book, 1874–1967’, NPG 77/1; ‘Register of Students’ Names and Addresses, 1896–1967’, NPG 77/2; and ‘Copyist Records: Applications to copy, Top Floor’, NPG 77/4. An ‘H. Allan’ also made copies of portraits of Tenniel (NPG 1596) in 1921 and Holman Hunt (NPG 1901) in 1935. Allen also specialized in posthumous portraits; see his portrait of Admiral Sir William Wharton (NPG 1497). See also Genes Reunited for possible details on H.M. Allen.
10) See two letters from C.J. Fitch to L. Cust, 25 Jan. 1907 and 28 Jan. 1907, both NPG RP 1453.
11) World, 26 Feb. 1907, no further details; cutting, NPG RP 1453.
12) Holmes replaced Lionel Cust as director of the NPG in October 1909. See Holmes 1910.
13) Letter from H.H. Child to C.J. Holmes, 16 Jan. 1910, NPG RP 1453.
14) Letter from C.J. Fitch to C.J. Holmes, 15 Feb. 1910, NPG RP 1453.
15) See letter from W.S. Brassington [Shakespeare Memorial] to C.J. Holmes, 19 Feb. 1910, NPG RP 1453.
16) See letter from D. Piper to [Shakespeare Memorial Theatre], 3 May 1967, asking that the Irving portrait be insured ‘at a valuation of £300’; and letter from [Shakespeare Memorial Theatre] to D. Piper, 6 May 1967, both NPG RP 1453.
Physical descriptionback to top
Three-quarter-length profile to left, standing, wearing morning dress, left hand in trouser pocket, blue-grey handkerchief in breast pocket, greying hair, brown eyes.
Provenanceback to top
Given by the Garrick Club, February 1907.
View all known portraits for Sir John Everett Millais, 1st Bt
Watch our playlist exploring scientific techniques used by the Gallery to unlock the secrets behind our Tudor portraits.
Subjects and themes
Search the collection by themes - from pets to weddings!
Black History Month
Take a tour exploring our Collection created by Alayo Akinkugbe for Black History Month in 2020.
A Picture of Health
Learn about pioneers in medicine, health and social reform from 1840 to 1920.