5 of 36 portraits of Florence Nightingale
- Extended catalogue entry
by Jerry Barrett
Pencil and watercolour on sketchbook paper, two sheets collated onto a single mount, 1856
6 3/4 in. x 4 3/8 in. (170 mm x 110 mm) overall
Inscriptionback to top
Left-hand sheet inscr. in pencil by the artist: ‘Florence Nightingale / Barrack Hospital / Scutari’;
inscr. in pencil by Henry Newman: ‘Drawn by / Jerry Barrett.’;
inscr. in pencil by ?H.T. Neild: ‘National Gallery of [?]Portraits’.
On reverse inscr. by ?Newman: ‘a a. hutch. / Burial ground. / Hamal carrying / a piano in a case’.
Right-hand sheet inscr. in pencil by the artist: ‘Florence Nightingale’;
dated in paint, lower right: ‘27.7.1856’.
This portraitback to top
To ensure the success of his second Crimean picture Jerry Barrett knew he must go the extra mile. For the first picture, Queen Victoria’s First Visit to her Wounded Soldiers, 1856 (NPG 6203), he had been praised for the truthfulness of the portraits, sketched as ‘the affecting incident took place’ at the Brompton Hospital, Chatham.  To succeed with the next subject – Florence Nightingale nursing soldiers at the Barrack Hospital, Scutari – he would have to go to Turkey, and soon, as a peace treaty had been signed on 30 March and the troops were being transported home.
Barrett went in the knowledge that Nightingale ‘had refused everybody, and would not allow her likeness to be taken’.  He travelled with a friend, Henry Newman, one of whose jobs was to smooth Barrett’s path: ‘I am fully employed in attending on Jerry and making an occasional sketch,’ he wrote from Scutari.  So Newman distracted Nightingale in the Scutari studio while Barrett drew her; as Newman’s nephew later wrote, ‘Florence Nightingale, though unwilling to sit, did show interest in the picture [see NPG 4305], and its progress. During her visits while she was enjoying not only Henry Newman’s graphic and beautiful sketches, but also his own interesting personality, Jerry Barrett was quietly occupied in making careful sketches of her which proved invaluable.’ 
The profiles in NPG 3303 were also obtained opportunistically. The date recorded in Barrett’s inscription ‘27.7.1856’ was the eve of Nightingale’s departure, by which time she and the artist were surely off speaking terms; she looks cross and tired, and Mark Bostridge suggests the images were sketched as she walked by the harbour.  Confusingly, the profiles were discovered in Newman’s sketchbook – perhaps Barrett grabbed it at an unexpected opportunity. Examination of Newman’s Syria and Palestine sketchbook at Friends’ House Library, London, confirms that the Nightingale profiles in NPG 3303 are indeed by Barrett, as Newman’s drawings were never so bold or confident; notations on these pages are, however, by both men.
The National Portrait Gallery was offered the sketches as a gift by Newman’s granddaughter in January 1946:
Herewith enclosed two sketches of Florence Nightingale, found in the sketch-books of the late Henry Newman. He & his artist friend Jerry Barrow [sic], went to Scutari & they found, it is said, the greatest difficulty in getting a sketch, as the lady was not interested. Donor is the late Miss H.T. Neild granddaughter of Hy. Newman. 
The Gallery was interested, and wanted to know if the drawings were by Barrett or Newman. The reply was inconclusive:
The story goes that Flo Nightingale disliked the idea of having her portrait taken, but Jerry Barrett got the sketches done while Henry Newman exerted his personal charm on the lady & diverted her attention from J.B.’s activities. The sketch on the back of the two heads is by Newman – so I cannot tell – & no one seems able to make a positive statement. 
The Nightingale sketches came on two little sheets: one with two watercolour profiles and the other with a pencil profile outline. They were accepted in February 1946 as ‘probably’ by Jerry Barrett and given a single accession number, NPG 3303.  The profiles bear no relation to the portrait of Nightingale in The Mission of Mercy (NPG 6202), which Barrett finished painting in 1857.
For other works at the Gallery directly connected to Barrett’s Crimean War paintings see NPG 2939; NPG 2939a; NPG 4305; NPG 6202; NPG 6203; and NPG D43044.
Footnotesback to top
1) AJ, 1858, p.191.
2) See [Newman] 1910, p.551.
3) ‘Henry Newman with his love of travel and art, readily accompanied his friend and former school fellow’ ([Newman] 1910, pp.543, 545). Newman (1818–1908) was a bookseller and artist from Leominster, Herefs.; a Quaker, his papers were deposited at Friends’ House L., London.
4) [Newman] 1910, p.552.
5) Bostridge 2008, p.266. See NPG 6202 for further details.
6) Letter from E.M. Grantham to NPG, 17 Jan. 1946, NPG RP 3303. Present whereabouts of Newman’s 1856 Scutari sketchbook are unknown.
7) Letter from E.M. Grantham to C.K. Adams, 24 Jan. 1946, NPG RP 3303.
8) ‘Drawings of 1856, probably by Jerry Barrett. Presented February 1946, in accordance with the wishes of Miss H.T. Neild. Two pages from a sketchbook belonging to Henry Newman who was a fellow traveller with the artist. (1) Two heads in pencil and watercolour in profile facing to left, wearing a bonnet. On the reverse a landscape with figures inscr. ‘MYDER PACHA’ and ‘CEMETARY’. (2) Head in pencil in profile facing left, wearing a bonnet’ (NPG Report of the Trustees 1945–46 (typescript)).
Physical descriptionback to top
Left-hand sheet: head, pencil outline, profile to left in bonnet. On reverse: sketch of man with box on back.
Right-hand sheet: two heads (one above the other), pencil and watercolour, profiles to left, pinkish nose and short hair under grey bonnet with lace and ribbons. On reverse: watercolour landscape by Henry Newman.
Conservationback to top
Provenanceback to top
Henry Newman; by descent to Miss H.T. Neild, by whose wish given to the Gallery, February 1946.
View all known portraits for Florence Nightingale
Watch our playlist exploring scientific techniques used by the Gallery to unlock the secrets behind our Tudor portraits.
Subjects and themes
Search the collection by themes - from pets to weddings!
Black History Month
Take a tour exploring our Collection created by Alayo Akinkugbe for Black History Month in 2020.
A Picture of Health
Learn about pioneers in medicine, health and social reform from 1840 to 1920.